Skip to content
Every offer answered by a person within 12 business hours.How it works
IRON WITHINCOLLECTIBLES
1957 Pro Stars #23 — Walter Greaves, graded SGC 6, in its holder

Photographed in our own light, unedited beyond cropping. Ask for raw angled shots of any corner or the reverse and we will send them the same day.

The honest description

The illustration has not faded — the browns are still warm and the pale sky has no foxing.

There is light surface creasing in the top-left border, which is what holds the grade at 6. No crease touches the artwork.

Honestly priced mid-grade vintage is the most collectible thing in the hobby right now, and this is a clean example of it.

Card record

Set
1957 Pro Stars, card #23
Grader
SGC 6 (EX-NM)
Certificate
9207744-011
Flaw disclosed
Light border creasing, top-left
Centering
58/42 top-bottom
Provenance
Estate purchase, Oklahoma, 2026
Verify it yourself
Sportscard Guaranty Company certificate 9207744-011 — look it up on the grader's own site before you offer.

What this has been trading at

Public sales we could verify for the same card in comparable grades. We publish the ones that hurt our asking price as well as the ones that help it.

DateGradeVenuePrice
Jul 2026SGC 6Online marketplace$1,180
Jun 2026PSA 6Weekly card auction$1,050
Apr 2026SGC 8Major auction house$3,400
Accepting offersSGC6Pop 67, with 96 graded higher

1957 Pro Stars #23 — Walter Greaves

Pro Stars · Painted issue · SGC 6

Honest mid-grade vintage. The painted art is bright, the crease everyone worries about is not there, and it costs a third of the same card two grades up.

Make an offer

Answered in 12 business hours

$1,120asking

$

An offer is not a payment and costs you nothing. At or above the asking price the card is reserved for 24 hours in your name; below it, a person reads it and answers with a yes, a no, or a counter.

  • Lifetime authenticity guarantee — we buy it back if it is ever not what the label says.
  • Shipped insured for the full amount, signature required, inside two business days of payment.
  • Three-day inspection window on every card, holder unbroken.

Also open to offers

See the whole vault →