
1957 Pro Stars #23 — Walter Greaves
$1,120
Asking
Honest mid-grade vintage. The painted art is bright, the crease everyone worries about is not there, and it costs a third of the same card two grades up.

Photographed in our own light, unedited beyond cropping. Ask for raw angled shots of any corner or the reverse and we will send them the same day.
Orange and red borders from this era almost always show white chipping along the edges. This one shows a trace at one corner and nothing else.
Colour registration is tight — the black nameplate is crisp rather than doubled, which is a print-run quality most of this set missed.
Light roller mark across the lower background, visible at an angle. It is disclosed on the listing and it is why this is a 7.
Public sales we could verify for the same card in comparable grades. We publish the ones that hurt our asking price as well as the ones that help it.
| Date | Grade | Venue | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 2026 | PSA 7 | Weekly card auction | $2,780 |
| Jun 2026 | PSA 7 | Online marketplace | $2,490 |
| May 2026 | PSA 8 | Major auction house | $5,900 |
Kickoff Classics · Rookie card · PSA 7
Orange border with no chipping worth the word, strong focus on the portrait, and a reverse that has never met a thumbtack.

$1,120
Asking
Honest mid-grade vintage. The painted art is bright, the crease everyone worries about is not there, and it costs a third of the same card two grades up.

$4,900
Asking
Serial 25/25 — the last card off the run — in a gem-mint holder with a population of four. Chrome parallels almost never survive the cut this clean.

$2,400
Asking
The chase card of the first wave, in a 9.5 with the iridescent border intact. The modern animation market's single most requested slab at this desk.